Mastering API Calculation Formula in Cleaning Validation

In the pharmaceutical industry, precision isn’t optional—it’s a regulatory mandate. Among the most critical practices in ensuring drug safety and quality is cleaning validation, which prevents cross-contamination between drug products. At the core of this validation is the formula—a scientifically grounded method for determining how much of an active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) may remain after cleaning, without compromising patient safety. This often requires adjustment to account for factors such as moisture content and different salt forms of APIs to ensure accurate dosing in compounded formulations. Additionally, thorough analysis is crucial in calculating the potency or assay of APIs, ensuring that all factors are considered for accurate potency in pharmaceutical formulations.

‍

For pharmaceutical professionals—from CEOs and plant heads to QC and lab leads—mastering these calculations ensures not just regulatory compliance but also operational excellence.

‍

‍

Key Terms Every Pharmaceutical Professional Should Know

Before applying any formula, it’s essential to understand the core concepts:

• API (Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient): The pharmacologically active compound in a drug product.
• MACO (Maximum Allowable Carryover): The calculated limit of residual API that can be carried over to the next product.
• ADE (Acceptable Daily Exposure): A health-based threshold for human exposure to an API.
• NOEL (No Observed Effect Level): The highest exposure level with no observable adverse effects.
• LD50 (Lethal Dose 50%): An older metric showing the dose that kills 50% of a test group.
• Safety Factor (SF): A conservative multiplier used to address uncertainty in toxicity data.
• Certificate of Analysis (CoA): A document that confirms the quality and moisture content of APIs, ensuring the accuracy of potency calculations and necessary adjustments for pharmaceutical formulations.
• Common Activity: Calculating the potency of APIs is a routine task for pharmacists, crucial for ensuring accurate dosing and efficacy in compounded formulations.

‍

‍

Breaking Down the Formulas

Different cleaning validation scenarios require different approaches. Accurately determining the concentration of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) is crucial in compounded preparations to ensure the correct dosage and efficacy of medications. Here are the most widely accepted API formula used in the pharmaceutical industry:

Factor adjustment is also important for calculating the potency or assay of APIs, as it accounts for elements such as moisture content and salt removal.

1. Therapeutic Dose-Based MACO Formula

This classic method uses clinical dosage data to calculate acceptable carryover. The quantity of an API must be measured meticulously to ensure accurate potency calculations. Precise measurements are crucial for calculating the potency of APIs, taking into account factors like moisture content and variations in ingredient forms.

• Best For: Common APIs with well-known therapeutic doses.
• Pros: Simple and straightforward.
• Cons: May not be suitable for highly potent or toxic substances.

2. Health-Based Exposure Limits (HBELs) via Toxicological Data

More modern and preferred by regulators like EMA and ICH:

Or using Permitted Daily Exposure (PDE):

When calculating these limits, it is crucial to adjust for moisture content, as moisture can significantly affect the accuracy of API quantities in formulations. Proper consideration of moisture leads to more precise dosing and better therapeutic outcomes.

Additionally, the molecular weight of the API is an essential factor in accurate calculations. Considering the specific molecular weight of components is necessary during compounding and dispensing processes, especially when adjusting for factors like moisture content and salt forms.

• Best For: Highly potent APIs or those with known toxicological profiles.
• Pros: Scientifically rigorous and regulator-preferred.
• Cons: Requires expert toxicology input.

3. 10 ppm Criterion

• Best For: Legacy APIs with limited data.
• Pros: Simple baseline.
• Cons: Considered outdated and overly conservative.

Note: When calculating potency, it is crucial to adjust for water content and consider the specific forms of drugs, as these factors can significantly impact the handling of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs).

A pharmacological agent, or API, is the critical component in drug formulations that provides therapeutic effects. Unlike excipients, which serve no pharmacological purpose, APIs are essential for achieving the desired medical outcomes.

‍

🔍 Explore related guidance on Cleaning Validation ICH Guidelines.

‍

‍

Example Calculation Using the Therapeutic Dose Method

Let’s walk through a real-world example:

• Minimum Therapeutic Dose of Product A = 50 mg
• Batch Size of Product B = 100,000 tablets
• Safety Factor = 100
• Maximum Daily Dose of Product B = 4 tablets

Pharmacists play a crucial role in performing these calculations to ensure the accurate compounding and dispensing of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs).

The pharmacological effect of APIs is what provides the therapeutic benefits in medications, distinguishing them from excipients that do not have any pharmacological impact.

In this case, the cleaning process must ensure residues fall well below 12,500 mg to remain compliant.  

‍

‍

Aligning with Regulatory Guidance

Today’s regulators expect a shift from generic limits to health-based exposure limits. Ensuring compliance with regulatory guidance involves understanding the pharmacological or therapeutic activity of Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (APIs). Key references include:

• EMA: Strongly supports PDE-based calculations over 10 ppm.
• ICH Q7: Emphasizes validated cleaning procedures and scientific justification.
• ISPE/APIC: Provide structured calculation templates and frameworks.

APIs are essential for delivering pharmacological effects that can cure, treat, or prevent disease, distinguishing them from excipients, which do not have any therapeutic effect.

‍

‍

Analytical & Operational Considerations

A correct formula is only half the equation. Execution matters too:

• Validated Analytical Methods: Ensure methods like HPLC or TOC can detect below MACO limits. Pharmacists must utilize this information to ensure proper measurements and adherence to formulation requirements.
• Swab & Rinse Recovery Factors: Always adjust results to account for recovery efficiencies. Checking the label to determine the content and formulation of APIs is crucial, especially when the label specifies the API in a specific chemical form, indicating whether adjustments are needed for calculations related to potency or assay.
• Worst-Case Scenarios: Validate with APIs that are hardest to clean and smallest subsequent batch sizes.

‍

‍

Common Challenges in MACO Calculation

Lack of Toxicological Data

→ Solution: Use reputable literature, PDE databases, or consult a toxicologist.

For example, sitagliptin phosphate is an API that requires accurate potency calculations, especially when considering the differences between its phosphate salt form and its active moiety without the salt.

High MACO But Low Analytical Sensitivity

→ Solution: Either optimize detection methods or lower MACO using a stricter safety factor.

A formal statement should be made to document the calculations and adjustments necessary for accurate potency or assay of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs). This includes specific examples where moisture content and adjustments to the amount of API are clearly articulated, ensuring accurate potency information is conveyed to end users.

Varying Global Expectations

→ Solution: Standardize on PDE-based methods across facilities for global harmonization.

When calculating the potency of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) within dosage forms, it is crucial to determine the exact amount of API present in a single tablet. This includes considering factors such as moisture content and the presence of salts, which directly influence the efficacy and dosage adjustments required for each tablet formulation.

‍

‍

Best Practices for Sustainable Compliance

• SOPs for MACO Calculations: Detail each formula, when to use it, and scientific rationale. Ensure that calculations are performed at critical points in the compounding process to accurately determine the amount or concentration of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) over time.
• Dosage Accuracy: Verify that the correct amount of each ingredient is present in each unit of the formulation to ensure precise dosing.
• Cross-Functional Alignment: Involve QA, QC, Regulatory, and Production in reviews.
• Routine Updates: Reassess MACO values when formulations, batch sizes, or toxicity data change.
• Training: Regular workshops on potency calculation, specific API considerations, and formula selection.

‍

Need a smarter way to manage cleaning validation SOPs and documentation? Explore Leucine’s Compliance Platform.

‍

‍

Conclusion: From Formula to Pharma Confidence

In today’s data-driven pharmaceutical environment, the calculation formula isn’t just a regulatory requirement—it’s a cornerstone of patient safety, product quality, and operational control. Whether you're working with many active pharmaceutical ingredients, tackling salt removal, or refining assay calculations, applying the correct MACO formula ensures confidence and compliance.

As expectations evolve, so should your processes. Leverage modern tools, update your documentation, and empower your teams to make informed decisions.

Keep learning: Read Cleaning Validation Guidelines for a deeper dive.

‍

‍